Some time around 2000, Triumph completely redesigned the crankcases and cylinder head of the T3 1200 motor. They had already done a redesign on the cases a few years earlier, doing away with the inspection cover over the starter and alternator gears. That change is not good news for anyone who suffers from the famous broken sprag clutch problem. The final change seems to me to have brought a lot of the design ideas used on the T5 engines across to the 1200 four whilst retaining the same cam cover, timing cover and sump castings for some reason. The clutch, LH crank and sprocket covers are all completely different.
I had been looking out for a cheap late Trophy 1200 engine for a while, just to play with as much as anything. Well, eventually one turned up at a very reasonable price in grotty and 'as seen' condition. I just wanted something to strip it to see how Triumph finished off the T3s so the fact that it was ropey didn't worry me too much.
From the RHS, the simpler construction is obvious. The head is visibly similar to the T595, with two external M6 bolts outboard of the camchain and vestigial finning. The clutch cover is also much simplified and incorporates the oil filler. Breathing is through the LH crank cover on these motors, rather than in the clutch cover. The sprocket cover is not longer oil bearing. A sight glass is fitted beneath it.
LHS of late motor, 'breathing' crank cover and oil sight glass. |
The oil was very thick, almost treacle-like in consistency. On the other hand, I had expected to find a considerable amount of shrapnel in the sump. Not at all - just some aluminium shavings that looked to me as if they were left over from manufacture. And instant gasket, no doubt washed down from the head where it had been generously applied at some point.
The internals looked pretty clean - no obvious signs of breakage or wear, just the treacly oil. The motor was not seized. I span it over on a starter and jump leads to test the sprags. They seemed fine but at this point it became clear that the engine had zero compression. It was easy to turn over by hand.
I checked the valve clearances in case they had all closed up but they were all fine. So it was time to lift the cams and head.
This is where things started to get hard. The cam cap bolts were incredibly tight. They are only supposed to be torqued to a modest figure (10 NM) but I was struggling to get them moving with a tommy bar on a 1/2inch socket. I broke three of my torx T30 bits doing this. In the end, I bought a special tough T30 bit from Screwfix and a new set of locking pliers. The worst ones were outboard of the camchain. These caps are particular important because the oil supply to the cams is delivered through them.
Cam bearing caps removed after a big fight, I can pull the valve buckets |
Separate compartments in a sorter box to keep the buckets from being muddled up |
Cylinder head bolts in varying condition, centre right sheered off |
A very manky head gasket. |
Cylinder 4, with broken head bolt visible top right. |
Cylinders 3 and 2, broken bolt bottom left |
The coolant passages in the head gasket are nearly all obstructed by crusty burnt oil, as are the passages in the head casting itself. The outside of the liners are encrusted in burnt oil. However, the cylinder bores look in really good condition - I can see the honing marks from manufacture on all of them. It seems to me as though oil from the head somehow got into the cylinders it blew through the water jacket. There was no obvious sign of oil around the jointed face outside of the engine. I'm guessing when the gasket went, it blew all of the coolant out of the bike. Must have been dramatic, to say the least.
The liners are very tight in the cases. I shall have to think carefully about how to free them off. I might try to drift them free from beneath, if I go ahead and split the cases.
6 comments:
Just to play ... I believe you might be kidding yourself monsieur.
Has it overheated and warped the head? Was there really no compression as in zip, nada, zero ..... or just a little bit?
What's the normal finish on the outside of the liners/inside of the block? That black gunk in there; is it really burnt oil/combustion residue or is simply oil stained casting marks? I struggle to see how a motor could run for long enough in that state to stain it that much.
Ooh that looks fun!
Well I could be kidding myself. For forty quid, it doesn't really matter:
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/140978999861
I didn't measure the compression with a gauge - just by feel. I was spinning the motor over with speed brace on the end of the crank so it is probably fairer to say very little rather than none.
The gunk is very oily at the front of the motor, more biscuity at the back. It could be a warped head. That would better explain the oiliness. I'll try to check the head with a straight edge.
There is no sign of emulsification anywhere so the coolant doesn't seem to have got into the oil. Maybe the coolant escaped, causing the motor to overheat and then the oil got into the water jacket?
I'm going to try to get the liners out later on so I can see what the inside of the water jacket is like. I'm anticipating another interesting fight there :-)
I couldn't shift the liners. I could see a bit of movement in cylinder four but couldn't get enough purchase to lift it. I've squirted a generous quantity of WD40 around them in the hope that the crusty deposit will soften some more.
I found a good photo illustration of a late 1200 engine strip here:
http://www.racebikehire.com/Workshop/Triumph%20Trophy%201200/Engine%20Teardown%20Pics/slides/DSC_2796.html
That's how a cylinder head should look.
Thanks for this blog.
Do you know if a 97 motor fit a 91 both throphys
Should go right in. The motor mounts are the same. The engine breather arrangements are different but the 97 is simpler and better. Carbs, ignition pickups, exhaust, gearbox sprocket, radiator hoses are all compatible.
Post a Comment